AMENDED AND RESTATED CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
This Amended and Restated Settlement Agreement
(“Agreement”) is entered into between plaintiff Orin Safier (“Class
Representative” or “Plaintiff”) on behalf of himself, the Settlement Class
defined below, and the general public, on the one hand, and defendant Western
Digital Corporation (“WDC” or “Defendant”), on the other hand (collectively,
the “Parties”).
1.
RECITALS
1.1.
Plaintiff initially brought claims against
Defendant on March 22, 2005, when he joined Defendant in a similar action by
another individual against disk drive maker Seagate Technology, LLC
(“Seagate”). Both Defendant and Seagate
demurred for misjoinder and the demurrer was sustained. Thereafter, Plaintiff dismissed Defendant
from the original action without prejudice and on July 7, 2005, filed an action
against Defendant entitled Orin Safier v.
Western Digital Corporation, et al., in the Superior Court for the City and
County of San Francisco, Case No. CGC-05-442812.
1.2.
On August 17, 2005, Defendant removed the
Litigation to the Northern District of California, Case No. 05-03353 BZ.
1.3.
In the Litigation, Class Representative alleged
that in the sale and marketing of its hard disk drives, Defendant represented
that he and other hard disk drive purchasers would receive more useable storage
capacity than they actually received. In
particular, Class Representative alleged that in October of 2004 he purchased
an “80GB” hard disk drive manufactured by WDC that contains only 74.4GB of
usable memory. Class Representative
claimed that Defendant’s actions constituted false advertising, unfair business
practices, breach of contract, fraud, and violations of the California
Consumers Legal Remedies Act. Class
Representative sought restitution, damages, punitive damages, and injunctive
relief.
1.4.
Defendant denied all the allegations and
claims. Defendant also asserted
affirmative defenses.
1.5.
On September 27, 2005, the Parties engaged in
arms-length mediation conducted by the Hon. Justice Steven Stone (Ret.) at JAMS
in Orange County (the “Mediation”).
1.6.
Each of the terms herein set forth was reached
through arms-length negotiations, including without limitation, the
Mediation. It is agreed by and among the
undersigned, subject to the approval of the Court, on behalf of Defendant,
Class Representative, and the Settlement Class, that the Litigation and the
Released Claims shall be fully and finally compromised, settled, and released,
and that the Litigation shall be dismissed on the merits and with prejudice, on
the terms and conditions set forth herein.
1.7.
Nothing in this Settlement Agreement shall
constitute an admission of liability or be used as evidence of liability.
2.
PLAINTIFF’S
CLAIMS AND THE BENEFITS OF SETTLEMENT
Class
Counsel and the Class Representative believe that the claims asserted in the
Litigation have merit. Plaintiff’s suit
alleges that Defendant’s hard disk drives deliver approximately 7% less storage
capacity than advertised. According to
Plaintiff, when attached to most personal computers, a hard disk drive
advertised by Defendant as having “80GB” will only show an available capacity
of “74.4GB.” Plaintiff alleges that one
reason for this disparity is the use of two different measurements of a “GB.” Plaintiff alleges that computer operating
systems compute 1 GB as 1,073,741,824 bytes (the “Binary Definition”), but
Defendant and other hard disk drive manufacturers compute 1 GB as 1,000,000,000
bytes (the “Decimal Definition”). Were
the Litigation to proceed, Plaintiffs would seek to recover on behalf of the
Class one or more of the following remedies:
(a) the right to return their hard disk drives for a full refund; (b)
the right to keep their hard disk drives and receive a partial refund of the
amount they paid proportional to the amount of capacity that was not provided;
(c) statutory damages for each act of false advertising knowingly directed at a
senior citizen; and (d) punitive damages.
Class Counsel would also seek an injunction requiring Defendant to more
accurately disclose the storage capacity of its hard disk drives in
advertising, marketing materials, and packaging. Class Counsel believe that the most likely
recovery for the class, if any, would be a refund of a portion of the purchase
price paid for the hard disk drive, although the percentage refunded could be
lower than the percentage of storage capacity that was not provided. Class Counsel are informed that more than
five million of Defendant’s hard disk drives were sold in the aftermarket during
the period covered by this settlement.
Class Counsel estimate that the average purchase price of Defendant’s
hard disk drives during the period at issue in this Litigation was $150. If the Court required Defendant to refund 5%
of the purchase price of each hard disk drive purchased, Class Counsel believe
that the average refund would be $7.50.
Class
Counsel and the Class Representative have concluded, after due investigation
and after carefully considering the relevant circumstances and the applicable
law, that it would be in the best interests of the Class to enter into this
Settlement Agreement in order to avoid the uncertainties of litigation and to
assure that the benefits reflected herein are obtained for the Class. Class Counsel and the Class Representative
understand that there are numerous risks in continuing with this litigation,
including the possibility of being unable to achieve the following: (1) certify a class of purchasers, (2)
demonstrate that Defendant’s undisclosed use of the Decimal Definition was
misleading to reasonable consumers or otherwise constituted an unfair trade
practice, (3) prove damages on behalf of the Class and each Class Member, (4)
demonstrate knowing false advertising directed at a senior citizens, and (5)
show that injunctive relief should be awarded.
After due investigation and evaluation, Class Counsel and the Class
Representative consider the settlement set forth herein to be fair, reasonable,
adequate, and in the best interests of the Class.
Because
it is not technologically possible, the proposed Settlement does not call for
capacity to be added to Class Member’s hard disk drives. But the proposed settlement will provide each
Class Member with free backup and recovery software that can be used in conjunction
with his/her hard disk drive. Based on
Class Counsel’s investigation of the retail market for backup and recovery
software, Class Counsel believes that this software is comparable to products
that retail for $30 or more, and that in light of the risks of litigation,
providing this software adequately compensates class members for the loss that
Class Counsel believe they suffered in allegedly not getting the capacity
promised in Defendant’s advertisements.
3.
DEFENDANT’S DENIAL OF WRONGDOING AND LIABILITY
Defendant
has denied and continues to deny each and all of the claims and contentions
alleged by the Class Representative.
Defendant expressly has denied and continues to deny all charges of
wrongdoing or liability against it arising out of any of the conduct,
statements, acts, or omissions alleged, or that could have been alleged, in the
Litigation. Defendant also has denied
and continues to deny, inter alia,
the allegation that the Class Representative, the Class, or any other member of
the public has suffered damage or harm by reason of any conduct, statement,
act, or omission of Defendant.
Nonetheless,
Defendant has concluded that further conduct of the Litigation would be
protracted and expensive, and that it is desirable that the Litigation be fully
and finally settled in the manner and upon the terms and conditions set forth
in this Settlement Agreement. Neither
this Agreement, nor any of its terms or provisions, nor any of the negotiations
or proceedings connected with it, shall be construed as an admission or
concession by Defendant of the truth of any of the allegations in this Action.
4.
DEFINED TERMS
The
following shall be defined terms for purpose of this Agreement:
4.1.
“Agreement” or “Settlement Agreement” means this
Settlement Agreement, including all exhibits thereto.
4.2.
“Aftermarket” means that the disk drive was not
purchased as part of a computer assembled by an OEM but rather was purchased
separately.
4.3.
“Class” or “Class Members” or “Settlement Class”
means all persons and entities who purchased in the United States an
Aftermarket Western Digital Corporation hard disk drive between March 22, 2001
and February 15, 2006.
4.4.
“Class Benefit” means the benefit provided to
Class Members that is set forth in Section 6 of this Agreement.
4.5.
“Claim Form” means the online form required to
be filled out by Class Members who wish to redeem the Class Benefit, a copy of
which is attached as Exhibit 9.
4.6.
“Claims Period” means the period beginning on
the Notice Date and running until thirty (30) days after Final Approval.
4.7.
“Class Action Complaint” means the Complaint
filed on July 7, 2005.
4.8.
“Class Action Settlement” means the resolution
of the Litigation pursuant to the terms of this Agreement.
4.9.
“Class Representative” and “Plaintiff” means
Orin Safier.
4.10.
“Defendant” means Western Digital Corporation.
4.11.
“Defendant’s Counsel” means the law firm of
Irell & Manella LLP.
4.12.
“Defendant’s Web Site” or “Website” means that
Internet web site located at http://www.wdc.com.
4.13.
“Effective Date”
means the latest of: (i) the date
of final affirmance on an appeal, the expiration of the time for a petition for
review or certiorari, or if review or certiorari be granted, the date of final
affirmance following review pursuant to that grant; (ii) the date of final
dismissal of any appeal or the final dismissal of any proceeding on review; or
(iii) if no appeal is filed, the expiration date of the time for the filing or
noticing of any appeal from the Court’s judgment finally approving this
Agreement.
4.14.
“Excluded Class Members” means Western Digital
Corporation, its subsidiaries, and their respective directors, officers, and
employees; Judge Zimmerman and his immediate family; and any person who opts
out of the Class.
4.15.
“Final
Approval” means issuance of judgment granting final approval of this Class
Action Settlement.
4.16.
“Litigation” means Orin Safier v. Western Digital Corporation, et al., Superior Court
for the City and County of San Francisco, Case No. CGC-05-442812, and Orin Safier v. Western Digital Corporation,
District Court for the Northern District of California, Case No. 05-03353 BZ.
4.17.
“Long Form Settlement Notice” means the Notice
attached hereto as Exhibit 1.
4.18.
“Notice Date” means the first day on which the
Defendant mails, emails, posts, or otherwise disseminates notice of the
pendency of the Litigation and proposed settlement as provided in Section 7 of
this Agreement.
4.19.
“OEM” means original equipment manufacturer.
4.20.
“Parties” means Plaintiff and Defendant,
collectively.
4.21.
“Preliminary Approval Date” means the date upon
which the Court issues an order granting Preliminary Approval.
4.22.
“Preliminary Approval” means the preliminary
approval of this Class Action Settlement.
4.23.
“Released Claims” means the claims released as
set forth in Section 10 of this Agreement.
4.24.
“Released Parties” means Defendant and, in their
representative capacities, all of Defendant’s past and present officers,
directors, agents, designees, servants, sureties, attorneys, employees,
parents, associates, controlling or principal shareholders, general or limited
partners or partnerships, subsidiaries, divisions, affiliates, insurers, heirs,
and all successors or predecessors in interest, assigns, or legal
representatives.
4.25.
“Settlement Class Counsel,” “Class Counsel” or
“Plaintiff’s Counsel” means the law firm
of Gutride Safier LLP.
4.26.
“Settlement Notice” means the Notices attached
hereto as Exhibits 1 through 6.
4.27.
“Settlement Website” means the website located
at http://www.wdc.com/settlement.
4.28.
“Software” means the software described in
Section 6 of this Agreement.
5.
INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
Upon the Effective Date, Defendant shall include language that is
substantially similar to the following on its Website and, as soon as its
current packaging supply is depleted, but no later than six (6) months
following the Effective Date, on its product packaging:
“1 gigabyte (GB) = 1 billion bytes. Total accessible capacity varies depending
on operating environment.”
6.
CLASS BENEFIT
Class
Members will be entitled to receive the following: For ninety (90) days following the Effective
Date, Class Members who successfully complete the Claim Form prior to the
expiration of the Claim Period shall be entitled to download, from the Website,
Software with substantially all of the following capabilities and
features: data back up; data recovery; a
user interface to guide users through each step of the backup and recovery
process; ability to execute operations in the background and create full
backups without impacting users, applications, or the network; capability to
schedule backup scripts and jobs as needed; built-in file filters that allow
users to choose which files they want to include or exclude in the back-up;
copy files in native file format; restore files/folders from a backup; ability
to backup entire system into a backup set, which can be appended at a later
date; capability of creating a single or multiple file backup set which the
user can compress or encrypt for added security; progressive backup method
which only copies new or modified files and allows user to restore their
machine to any point in time with a single pass; choice of full, incremental,
and mirror backups; ability to duplicate data, including all necessary system
files to a secondary hard disk drive’s root level to make a bootable disk;
fully scriptable on Windows and Macintosh so that a user can create scripts
that force certain applications to close when the backup runs and re-open when
completed; if unable to backup an individual file, intelligence to retry that
file on the next operation until properly backed up; built-in schedulers that
allow users to create automated back-up, duplicate, and restore scripts to meet
their needs; detailed log reporting; option of backing up to a disk; protection
to ensure that backups do not exceed disk capacity; notification to users
regarding successful backups, failed backups, and other relevant information;
built-in software compression; encryption algorithm; password protection; data
grooming options for disk backup sets; restore option to replace existing files
on hard drives only if the backed up files are newer; restore option to restore
only files which exist in the backup but have been deleted from the hard
drives; duplicate option to replace existing files on hard drives only if the
copy on the source disk is newer; selectors for Documents and Settings, Office
Documents, Music, Movies, Pictures, Operating System, and Applications; DVD+R
DL (double layer) drives and media support; taskbar Icon and hot key backup;
catalog files automatically repaired when they become out of sync; supports the
following Windows operation systems:
Windows 98SE, ME, 2000, XP Pro and Home, NT 4, and Win XP 64-bit
OS; supports the following Macintosh
operation systems: Mac OS 10.1.5 and
later; localized in the following languages:
English, French, German, and Japanese; supports local, external,
removable, and network hard disk regardless of interface; capable of being
saved and re-used by Class Members.
7.
NOTICE
7.1.
As soon as possible but not later than five (5)
days following Preliminary Approval and Final Approval, WDC will send Notice,
in the form attached hereto as Exhibits 2 and 3, respectively, via electronic
mail to the last known electronic mail address of each registered purchaser for
whom it maintains an email address.
7.2.
As soon as possible but not later than five (5)
days following Preliminary Approval and Final Approval, WDC will send Notice,
in the form attached hereto as Exhibits 4 and 5, respectively, via US mail
to each registered purchaser for whom it maintains a mailing address but no
electronic mail address.
7.3.
The Settlement Website shall have the structure
and text per the mutual agreement of the Parties and shall contain the Notice
attached hereto as Exhibit 1, a copy of this Settlement Agreement, the Claim
Form, the Class Action Complaint, Plaintiff’s motion for preliminary approval,
and Defendant’s brief in support of preliminary approval, all in the .pdf and
.html formats.
7.4.
From no more than five (5) days following
Preliminary Approval until thirty (30) days after Final Approval, WDC shall
post a hyperlink on the bottom of the home page of its Website that links the
home page to the Settlement Website.
7.5.
No more than ten (10) days following Preliminary
Approval, WDC will place Notice in the USA Today, on two separate days, in the
form attached as Exhibit 6.
7.6.
Defendant shall provide the notices required by
28 U.S.C. § 1715 no later than ten (10) days after this Settlement Agreement is
submitted to the Court.
7.7.
WDC shall be responsible for making all
arrangements necessary to effectuate the Notices described herein and for
payment of the costs of such Notices.
8.
ELIGIBILITY FOR CLASS BENEFIT
8.1.
In order to receive the Class Benefit, each
Class Member must, no later than thirty (30) days after Final Approval,
complete and timely submit the Claim Form.
The sole purpose of the Claim Form is to demonstrate that the claimant
is a member of the Class and eligible for the Class Benefit, and neither WDC
nor Class Counsel shall use the information collected on the Claim Form for any
other purpose.
8.2.
Class Members may submit the Claim Form
electronically on the Settlement Website or may print the Claim Form and submit
it by U.S. Mail, according to the instructions on the Claim Form.
8.3.
Any Class Member who does not know the serial
number of the Class Member’s WDC hard disk drive must submit the Claim Form by
U.S. mail, along with a copy of their receipt or other original proof of
purchase of the hard disk drive, according to the instructions on the Claim
Form.
8.4.
Within five (5) days of the Effective Date, WDC
will notify, by electronic mail, all Class Members who timely and validly
completed the Claim Form and provided an e-mail address of their right to
download the Software. This notice shall
contain a link that permits Class Members to download the Software and shall
instruct Class Members that they must complete the download within ninety (90)
days of the Effective Date. Class
Members shall be permitted to transfer to others their right to download the
Software.
8.5.
Within five (5) days of the Effective Date, WDC
will provide to all Class Members who timely and validly completed the Claim
Form and who provided a U.S. mail address but no email address either a CD
containing the Software or a URL that permits Class Members to download the
software.
8.6.
WDC shall be responsible for processing the
Claim Form, providing the Notices, and administering the Class Benefit
redemption process described herein, and shall bear its own costs associated
therewith, except that Class Counsel shall be responsible for collecting any
opt-out requests and any Claim Forms submitted by mail and providing the Claim
Forms to WDC the day after the claims period ends, and shall bear their own
costs associated therewith. WDC shall
report to Class Counsel on the number of claimants and any significant issues
or problems in the administration of the Claims Form or the Settlement.
9.
OPTING OUT OF CLASS
9.1.
Any Class Member may opt-out of the Settlement
Class by submitting a written, signed request to opt-out, by postage-paid,
first class mail, with the following: (1) their name, address, and telephone
number, (2) reference to this Litigation (i.e., Orin Safier v. Western Digital Corporation, et al., Case No.
05-03353), (3) the serial number of the WDC hard drive(s) they purchased, (4)
the approximate date of purchase, and (5) a statement that they wish to opt-out
of the Class to:
WDC Settlement Opt Out
5654 Geary Blvd., #210511
San Francisco, CA 94121
9.2.
Any opt-out letter must be postmarked no later
than May 19, 2006.
10.
RELEASES
10.1.
The Class Representative (for himself and as
representative of the Settlement Class, and on behalf of each Class Member),
and their respective agents, successors, heirs, and assigns, shall be deemed to
have, and by operation of the Final Approval, shall have fully, finally, and
forever irrevocably released, relinquished, and discharged with prejudice the Released
Parties from any and all liabilities, claims, cross-claims, causes of action,
rights, actions, suits, debts, liens, contracts, agreements, damages,
restitution, disgorgement, costs, attorneys’ fees, losses, expenses,
obligations, or demands, of any kind whatsoever, whether in arbitration,
administrative, or judicial proceedings, whether as individual claims or as
claims asserted on a class basis or on behalf of the general public, whether
known or unknown, suspected or unsuspected, threatened, asserted, or
unasserted, actual or contingent, liquidated or unliquidated, whether under
federal statutory law, federal common law, federal regulation, or the statutory
or common laws or regulations of any and all states or subdivisions, to which
res judicata would apply if the Litigation had been litigated to a complete and
final judgment.
10.2.
Defendant and its agents, successors, heirs, and
assigns shall be deemed to have, and by operation of the Final Approval, shall
have fully, finally, and forever irrevocably released, relinquished, and
discharged with prejudice the Class Representative from any and all
liabilities, claims, cross-claims, causes of action, rights, actions, suits,
debts, liens, contracts, agreements, damages, restitution, disgorgement, costs,
attorneys’ fees, losses, expenses, obligations, or demands, of any kind
whatsoever, whether in arbitration, administrative, or judicial proceedings,
whether as individual claims or as claims asserted on a class basis or on
behalf of the general public, whether known or unknown, suspected or
unsuspected, threatened, asserted, or unasserted, actual or contingent,
liquidated or unliquidated, whether under federal statutory law, federal common
law, federal regulation, or the statutory or common laws or regulations of any
and all states or subdivisions, for malicious prosecution or costs.
11.
PAYMENTS TO CLASS REPRESENTATIVE AND COUNSEL
11.1.
Subject to Court approval, Defendant shall pay,
and will not contest the reasonableness of, a $1,000.00 incentive award to the
Class Representative, as compensation for the time and effort undertaken in and
risks of pursuing this litigation. Class
Representative shall not seek an incentive award greater than $1,000.00.
11.2.
Subject to Court approval, Defendant shall pay,
and will not contest the reasonableness of, an award of attorneys’ fees of up
to $485,000 and an award of expenses of up to $15,000. At Plaintiff’s request, Defendant will also
submit a statement to the Court in which this matter is pending stating that it
does not oppose a fee or cost request of up to the agreed amounts. Neither Class Counsel nor the Class
Representative shall seek an award of attorneys’ fees and costs greater than
the agreed amounts. Class Counsel and
the Class Representative agree that the denial, downward modification, or
failure to grant the request for attorneys’ fees and costs shall not constitute
grounds for termination of the settlement.
No portion of the fees and expenses awarded to Class Counsel shall be
shared with the Class Representative.
11.3.
Said awards, fees, and costs will be paid within
seven (7) days of the Effective Date. If
the Effective Date does not occur until after Final Approval, Defendant also
agrees to pay Class Counsel, within seven (7) days of the Effective Date,
interest on the total attorneys’ fee and expense award from the Final Approval
date through the Effective Date, calculated based on a 365 day year and
compounded monthly, at the “Preferred Rate Savings” rate for deposits of
$100,000 or more published for the California offices of Wells Fargo, N.A. as
of the date of Final Approval.
12.
PROCEDURE FOR CLASS CERTIFICATION AND APPROVAL
AND APPOINTMENT OF COUNSEL
12.1.
The parties agree to jointly submit this
Agreement to the Court and request that the Court enter an order in the form
attached as Exhibit 7 (the “Preliminary Approval Order”).
12.2.
Plaintiff, Defendant, Settlement Class Counsel,
and Defendant’s Counsel agree to recommend approval of and vigorously to
support this Settlement Agreement to the Court and to the Class Members and to
undertake their best efforts, including all reasonable steps and efforts
contemplated by this Settlement Agreement and any other reasonable steps and
efforts that may be necessary or appropriate, by order of the Court or
otherwise, to carry out the terms of this Settlement Agreement. The parties shall aggressively cooperate,
assist, and undertake all reasonable actions in order to accomplish the above
on a timely basis in accordance with the schedule established by the Court.
12.3.
Defendant is entitled to communicate with the
Class Members in the ordinary course of Defendant’s business. Nothing in this agreement shall prohibit
Defendant from answering questions from Class Members about this Class Action
and this Settlement Agreement. However,
Defendant will not aid or encourage any objections to this Settlement Agreement
(or any of its terms or provisions) nor to final certification of the
Settlement Class, nor encourage any Class Members to elect to opt-out.
12.4.
Settlement Class Counsel shall make all
reasonable efforts to enforce the jurisdictional and injunctive provisions of
this Settlement Agreement. Any time and
expense incurred by Plaintiff and Settlement Class Counsel to enforce the
jurisdictional and injunctive provisions or to monitor opt-outs shall be deemed
to be within the fees and costs awarded by the Court pursuant to Section 11.2
of this Agreement.
12.5.
Upon the Court’s final approval of this
Agreement and the settlement set forth herein, a judgment in the form attached
hereto as Exhibit 8 shall be entered.
12.6.
If any proceeding or action is commenced by any
federal, state, or local governmental authority in a parens patriae function (and not in its capacity as a Class Member
that has opted-out of the Settlement Class) asserting claims within the scope
of the Action, the Plaintiff and Settlement Class Counsel shall intervene in
that action at the request of Defendant.
Plaintiff shall intervene to fully support Defendant by asserting that
the governmental action is within the scope of this Agreement, the Class Action
Complaint, and the Judgment entered herein.
Any time and expense incurred for such intervention by the Plaintiff and
Settlement Class Counsel shall be deemed to be within the fees and costs
awarded by the Court pursuant to Section 11.2 of this Agreement. Additionally, in the event any action is
commenced by a governmental authority as stated in this paragraph, Defendant
shall have the option, in its sole discretion, to immediately suspend provision
of the Class Benefit to citizens of that jurisdiction pending the outcome of
the action brought by the governmental authority.
13.
TERMINATION OF AGREEMENT
13.1.
If this Agreement is terminated pursuant to
Section 13.5, if the Court does not
enter a Preliminary Approval Order that is substantially similar to the
order attached hereto as Exhibit 7, if the Court does not enter a Final
Approval Order that is substantially similar to the order attached hereto as
Exhibit 8, or if the Court’s Final Approval Order does not become final as a
result of an appeal or subsequent proceedings on remand, nothing herein shall
be deemed to prejudice the position of any of the Parties with respect to the
Litigation or otherwise, and neither the existence of this Agreement nor its
contents shall be admissible in evidence, referred to for any purpose in the
Litigation or in any other litigation or proceeding, or be deemed a
presumption, concession or admission by Plaintiff or WDC of any issue, fault,
liability, or wrongdoing, or of the existence of a certifiable class.
13.2.
Notwithstanding Section 13.1, the parties retain
any and all rights to assert a breach of the Agreement and to use this
Agreement in connection with such a claim.
13.3.
The certification of the Class shall be
effective only with respect to this settlement of the Litigation. In the event that the Agreement is terminated
pursuant to its terms or the Effective Date does not occur for any reason, the
certification of the Class shall be vacated, and the Litigation shall proceed
as though this Settlement had not been reached and the Class had never been
certified.
13.4.
In the event that the Agreement is terminated
pursuant to its terms or the Effective Date does not occur for any reason, the
Parties will be restored to their respective positions in the Litigation as of
September 27, 2005.
13.5.
WDC shall have the option to terminate this
Agreement in the event that the number of persons or entities who opt-out of
the Class exceeds 10,000.
14.
STAY OF PROCEEDINGS
All
proceedings in the Litigation, except as set forth herein or as necessary to
consummate the settlement for which this Agreement provides, will be stayed,
unless otherwise ordered by the Court.
15.
ADDITIONAL PROVISIONS
15.1.
This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement
between the Parties and supersedes all prior representations, negotiations, and
agreements relating to the subject matter of this Agreement, including without
limitation the Settlement Agreement between the Parties dated January 20, 2006,
and the Settlement Agreement between the Parties dated February 1, 2006.
15.2.
All terms of this Agreement are contractual and
not mere recitals. The terms are and shall be binding upon each of the parties
hereto, their agents, attorneys, employees, successors, and assigns, and upon
all other persons claiming any interest in the subject matter hereto through
any of the parties hereto, including any Class Member.
15.3.
This Agreement may be amended or modified only
by a written instrument signed by counsel for all parties. Amendments and
modifications may be made without notice to the Class Members unless the Court
requires notice.
15.4.
This Agreement shall be subject to, governed by,
construed, and enforced pursuant to the laws of the State of California.
15.5.
The exhibits to this Agreement are integral
parts of the Agreement and Settlement and are hereby incorporated and made a
part of this Agreement.
15.6.
To the extent permitted by law, this Agreement
may be pleaded as a full and complete defense to, and may be used as the basis
for an injunction against, any action, suit, or other proceeding that may be
instituted, prosecuted, or attempted in breach of this Agreement.
15.7.
This Agreement shall be deemed executed upon the
last date of execution by all of the undersigned counsel.
15.8.
This Agreement may be executed in counterparts,
each of which shall constitute an original. The several signature pages may be
collected and annexed to one or more documents to form a complete
counterpart. Photocopies of executed
copies of this Agreement may be treated as originals.
15.9.
All time periods and dates relating to the
approval of this Agreement and the notification of the class (but not those
relating to the substantive rights of the parties and Class Members, such as
those that are part of the class definition) are subject to approval and change
by the Court.
15.10.
No press announcement or press release
concerning the Litigation or the settlement thereof may be made by Class
Counsel or the Class Representative unless they obtain prior approval from
Defendant, which approval shall not be unreasonably withheld. Any press announcement, press release, or other
public statement concerning the Litigation or the settlement thereof shall
state that the settlement is not an admission of misconduct and that Defendant
denies any liability or wrongdoing and shall not include Defendant’s ticker
symbol.
15.11.
During the Litigation, Defendant has shared with
Class Counsel certain confidential documents, including but not limited to,
historical sales data. No later than ten
(10) days after the Effective Date, Class Counsel shall return to Defendant or
destroy all copies of such confidential documents.
15.12.
No part of this Agreement shall be admissible
against the Parties in this or any court, administrative, or other proceeding,
except for a proceeding to enforce the terms of this Agreement.
SO AGREED.
PLAINTIFF
Dated: _3/7____, 2006 By: /s/ Orin Safier
Orin Safier
WESTERN DIGITAL CORPORATION
Dated: _March 7, 2006 By: /s/ Raymond M. Bukaty
Its: Senior Vice President, Administration,
General
Counsel and Secretary
Approved as
to form:
GUTRIDE SAFIER LLP
Dated: _3/8____, 2006 By: /s/ Adam Gutride
Adam Gutride, Esq.
Seth A. Safier, Esq.
Attorneys for Plaintiff Orin Safier
IRELL & MANELLA, LLP
Dated: _3/7____, 2006 By: /s/ Scott D. Baskin
Scott Baskin, P.C.
Attorneys for Defendant
Western Digital Corporation
NOTICE OF CLASS ACTION AND PROPOSED SETTLEMENT (“NOTICE”)
TO: ALL PERSONS AND ENTITIES WHO PURCHASED IN
THE UNITED STATES AN AFTERMARKET WESTERN DIGITAL CORPORATION HARD DISK DRIVE
FROM MARCH 22, 2001 TO FEBRUARY 15, 2006.
THIS NOTICE MAY AFFECT YOUR RIGHTS.
PLEASE READ THE COMPLETE NOTICE CAREFULLY.
I. Purpose of this Notice.
There is now pending in the District Court for the Northern
District of California a class action lawsuit entitled Orin Safier v.
Western Digital Corporation, Case No. 05-03353 BZ (the “Litigation”). This Notice explains the nature of the
Litigation and the general terms of a proposed settlement, and informs you of
your legal rights and obligations.
Unless otherwise set forth, this Notice incorporates by reference the
definitions set forth in the Class Action Settlement Agreement.
Safier (“Plaintiff”) filed a class action lawsuit against Western
Digital Corporation (“Defendant” or “WDC”) on behalf of the Class described
above. Plaintiff alleges that in the
sale and marketing of its hard disk drives, Defendant overstates the useable
storage capacity by approximately 7%.
According to Plaintiff, when attached to most personal computers, a hard
disk drive advertised by Defendant as having “80GB” will only show an available
capacity of “74.4GB.” Plaintiff alleges
that one reason for this disparity is the use of two different measurements of
a “GB.” Plaintiff alleges that computer
operating systems compute 1 GB as 1,073,741,824 bytes (the “Binary
Definition”), but Defendant and other hard disk drive manufacturers compute 1
GB as 1,000,000,000 bytes (the “Decimal Definition”). Plaintiff alleges that Defendant’s conduct
constituted false advertising, unfair business practices, breach of contract,
fraud, and violations of the California Consumers Legal Remedies Act. In the Litigation, Plaintiff would seek to
recover on behalf of the Class one or more of the following remedies: (a) the right to return their hard disk
drives for a full refund; (b) the right to keep their hard disk drives and
receive a partial refund of the amount they paid proportional to the amount of
capacity that was not provided; (c) statutory damages for each act of false
advertising knowingly directed at a senior citizen; and (d) punitive
damages. Class Counsel also seek an
injunction requiring Defendant to more accurately disclose the storage capacity
of its hard disk drives in advertising, marketing materials, and packaging.
Class Counsel and the Class Representative have concluded, after
due investigation and after carefully considering the relevant circumstances
and the applicable law, that it would be in the best interests of the Class to
enter into this Settlement Agreement in order to avoid the uncertainties of
litigation and to assure that the benefits reflected herein are obtained for
the Class. Class Counsel believe that
the most likely recovery for the class, if any, would be a refund of a portion
of the purchase price paid for the hard disk drive, although the percentage
refunded could be lower than the percentage of storage capacity that was not
provided. Class Counsel are informed
that more than five million of Defendant’s hard disk drives were sold in the
aftermarket during the period covered by this settlement. Class Counsel estimate that the average
purchase price of Defendant’s hard disk drives during the period at issue in
this Litigation was $150. If the Court
required Defendant to refund 5% of the purchase price of each hard disk drive
purchased, Class Counsel believe that the average refund would be $7.50. Class Counsel and the Class Representative
understand, however, that there are numerous risks in continuing with this
litigation, including the possibility of being unable to achieve the
following: (1) certify a class of
purchasers, (2) demonstrate that Defendant’s undisclosed use of the Decimal
Definition was misleading to reasonable consumers or otherwise constituted an
unfair trade practice, (3) prove damages on behalf of the Class and each Class Member,
(4) demonstrate knowing false advertising directed at a senior citizens, and
(5) show that injunctive relief should be awarded. After due investigation and evaluation, Class
Counsel and the Class Representative consider the settlement set forth herein
to be fair, reasonable, adequate, and in the best interests of the Class.
Because it is not technologically possible, the proposed
Settlement does not call for capacity to be added to Class Member’s hard disk
drives. But the proposed settlement will
provide each Class Member with free backup and recovery software that can be
used in conjunction with his/her hard disk drive. Based on Class Counsel’s investigation of the
retail market for backup and recovery software, Class Counsel believes that
this software is comparable to products that retail for $30 or more, and that
in light of the risks of litigation, providing this software adequately
compensates class members for the loss that
Class Counsel believe they suffered in allegedly not getting the capacity
promised in Defendant’s advertisements.
Defendant denies Plaintiff’s allegations, any wrongdoing, and any
liability whatsoever and believes it has many legal defenses to all of the
claims asserted by Plaintiff. Defendant
believes that its marketing and advertising complied and continues to comply in
all respects with the law and that no Class Member, including the Plaintiff,
has sustained any damages or injuries related to its actions or omissions. Nonetheless, Defendant has concluded that further
conduct of the Litigation would be protracted and expensive, and that it is
desirable that the Litigation be fully and finally settled in the manner and
upon the terms and conditions of the proposed settlement.
Judge Bernard Zimmerman of the District Court for the Northern
District of California (also referred to as the “Court”) has preliminarily
determined that this Litigation should proceed as a class action, for purposes
of settlement only, with Safier (“Plaintiff”) as the representative of the Class,
and has granted preliminary approval of the proposed settlement.
II. Class Members.
The Court has conditionally ruled that the Litigation may be
maintained on behalf of the following:
ALL PERSONS AND ENTITIES WHO
PURCHASED IN THE UNITED STATES AN AFTERMARKET WESTERN DIGITAL CORPORATION HARD
DISK DRIVE FROM MARCH 22, 2001 TO FEBRUARY 15, 2006.
Excluded from being Class Members
are Western Digital Corporation, its directors, officers, and employees; Judge
Zimmerman and the members of his immediate family; and all persons who timely
and validly request exclusion from the Class.
“Aftermarket” means that the disk
drive was not purchased as part of a computer assembled by an OEM but rather
was purchased separately. Non-excluded
persons and entities that fall within the above definition are referred to as
“Class Members.”
III. Settlement Benefit For Class Members.
A. If the settlement
is finally approved by the Court, WDC will include language substantially
similar to the following on its website and, as soon as its current packaging
supply is depleted, but no later than six (6) months following the Effective
Date, on its product packaging:
“1 gigabyte (GB) = 1 billion bytes. Total accessible capacity varies depending on
operating environment.”
B. If the proposed
settlement is finally approved by the Court, WDC will provide to Class Members
the following “Class Benefit:”
For ninety (90) days following the
Effective Date, all Class Members who successfully complete a Claim Form prior
to the expiration of the Claim Period shall be entitled to download, from the
Website, software with substantially all of the following capabilities and
features: data back up; data recovery; a user interface to guide users through
each step of the backup and recovery process; ability to execute operations in
the background and create full backups without impacting users, applications,
or the network; capability to schedule backup scripts and jobs as needed;
built-in file filters that allow users to choose which files they want to
include or exclude in the back-up; copy files in native file format; restore
files/folders from a backup; ability to backup entire system into a backup set,
which can be appended at a later date; capability of creating a single or
multiple file backup set which the user can compress or encrypt for added
security; progressive backup method which only copies new or modified files and
allows user to restore their machine to any point in time with a single pass;
choice of full, incremental, and mirror backups; ability to duplicate data,
including all necessary system files to a secondary hard disk drive’s root
level to make a bootable disk; fully scriptable on Windows and Macintosh so
that a user can create scripts that force certain applications to close when
the backup runs and re-open when completed; if unable to backup an individual
file, intelligence to retry that file on the next operation until properly
backed up; built-in schedulers that allow users to create automated back-up,
duplicate, and restore scripts to meet their needs; detailed log reporting;
option of backing up to a disk; protection to ensure that backups do not exceed
disk capacity; notification to users regarding successful backups, failed
backups, and other relevant information; built-in software compression;
encryption algorithm; password protection; data grooming options for disk
backup sets; restore option to replace existing files on hard drives only if
the backed up files are newer; restore option to restore only files which exist
in the backup but have been deleted from the hard drives; duplicate option to
replace existing files on hard drives only if the copy on the source disk is
newer; selectors for Documents and Settings, Office Documents, Music, Movies,
Pictures, Operating System, and Applications; DVD+R DL (double layer) drives
and media support; taskbar Icon and hot key backup; catalog files automatically
repaired when they become out of sync; supports the following Windows operation
systems: Windows 98SE, ME, 2000, XP Pro
and Home, NT 4, and Win XP 64-bit OS;
supports the following Macintosh operation systems: Mac OS 10.1.5 and later; localized in the
following languages: English, French,
German, and Japanese; supports local, external, removable, and network hard
disk regardless of interface; capable of being saved and re-used by Class
Members.
IV. Claims Process and Deadline.
A. Claims
Process. Only one Class Benefit is
available for each Class Member. In
order to receive the Class Benefit, Class Members must complete the Claim Form
available at http://www.wdc.com/settlement by (1) providing their name
and postal or e-mail address; (2) providing the estimated date of purchase of a
WDC hard disk drive; (3) providing the serial number for the WDC hard disk
drive they purchased or a copy of their receipt or other proof of purchase; and
(4) attesting, under penalty of perjury, that their WDC hard disk drive was not
purchased from an OEM, that they have registered for only one Class Benefit,
and that the information provided is correct.
Such information is to be used only for purposes of administering this
Settlement. Excluded Class Members are
not eligible to receive the Class Benefit.
Class Members may submit the Claim Form electronically on the Settlement
Website or print the Claim Form and submit it by U.S. mail to: WDC Settlement
Claim Form; 5654 Geary Blvd., #210511; San Francisco, CA 94121, according to
the instructions on the Claim Form.
B. Claims
Deadline. Class Members must complete
the Claim Form no later than thirty (30) days after Final Approval of the
Settlement. Class Members who do not
complete the Claim Form by that date will not be eligible to receive the Class
Benefit.
V. Dismissal of Litigation, Entry of
Judgment and Release of Claims.
If the Court approves the proposed settlement, i